Why Won’t My Keloid Scar Stop Growing?

keloids treatment

A Doctor’s Guide to Understanding and Treating Stubborn Keloid Scars –

It usually starts with something minor like a small acne blemish, an ear piercing, or a routine surgical incision. For most people, the skin heals normally, leaving behind a flat mark that fades over time. But for some, the healing process goes into overdrive, resulting in a thick, raised, and sometimes tender growth that extends well beyond the original injury.

If you are watching a mark continue to grow long after the wound has closed, you are likely dealing with a keloid scar. Here is a clinical breakdown of why these stubborn scars form and the treatments we use to successfully manage them.

What is Happening Beneath a Keloid Scar?

When your skin is injured, your body sends collagen – a structural protein – to repair the damage. In a normal healing process, collagen production stops once the wound is closed.

In a keloid scar, the body’s cellular signalling misfires. The skin continues to pump out excess collagen long after the injury has healed, creating dense, thick bundles of scar tissue. Unlike a standard raised scar (known as a hypertrophic scar) which stays strictly within the original wound area, a keloid scar aggressively expands into the healthy surrounding skin. Depending on your skin type, a keloid scar may appear purplish-red or present as a dark, hyperpigmented bump.

Common Triggers for Keloid Scars

A keloid scar does not form on everyone. They are heavily influenced by genetics and occur more frequently in individuals with darker skin types.

While a keloid scar can form from almost any minor skin trauma, they most commonly develop in areas where the skin is tight or under tension, including:

  • The chest and shoulders
  • Earlobes (especially after ear piercing)
  • The upper arms and upper back
  • Jawline and cheeks (often following cystic acne)

Effective Treatments for Keloid Scars

Treating a keloid scar requires a highly strategic approach. Because your skin has already proven that it overreacts to trauma, simply cutting a keloid scar out through standard surgery is rarely a good idea on its own, it frequently results in a new keloid scar that is even larger than the original.

Effective management requires suppressing that overactive healing response through one or a combination of the following therapies:

  • Steroid Injections for Keloid Scars: The gold standard for flattening keloid scars. Injecting a medical corticosteroid directly into the scar tissue breaks down the excess collagen, takes away the redness, and relieves itchiness and tenderness. This typically requires a series of treatments spaced several weeks apart.
  • Cryotherapy: Freezing the tissue with liquid nitrogen can reduce the hardness and size of the keloid scar. We sometimes use cryotherapy immediately before a steroid injection, as the freezing makes the dense scar tissue much easier to treat.
  • Skin Surgery with Preventative Care: While standard excision is risky, surgical removal can be highly successful if followed immediately by preventative measures. When we remove a keloid scar, we combine the procedure with immediate steroid injections or specialised pressure dressings to stop the scar from coming back.
  • Clinical Skincare: Post-procedure scar management is critical. We often recommend clinical-grade topical formulations, such as silicone cream or silicone patches, to hydrate the tissue and regulate collagen production while the skin heals.

Don’t Wait to Address a Growing Keloid Scar

Because keloid scars continue to grow over time, early medical intervention yields the best cosmetic results. If you suspect a healing wound is turning into a keloid scar, or if you have an older scar causing discomfort, a proper skin assessment is the first step toward flattening the tissue.

To explore the right treatment plan for your skin, book a consultation with Dr. Ankur Bansal at Advanced Skin Doctors. We provide specialised skin assessments and surgical procedures across our clinics in Frankston, Wheelers Hill, Narre Warren, and Hoppers Crossing.

About the Author:

Dr. Ankur Bansal is a principal doctor at Advanced Skin Doctors, specialising in skin cancer medicine, dermoscopy, and skin surgery. With extensive experience in complex skin procedures and scar management, Dr. Bansal provides evidence-based treatments across clinics in Frankston, Wheelers Hill, Narre Warren, and Hoppers Crossing.

Summary: Understanding the gist of Keloid Scars

A keloid scar is an overgrowth of scar tissue that extends beyond the original wound because of excessive collagen production during healing. Keloids can develop after acne, piercings, surgery or other skin injuries. They may cause itching, tenderness or discomfort and usually do not flatten without treatment.

Keloid scar treatment aims to reduce scar thickness, relieve symptoms and manage further growth. Options include corticosteroid injections, silicone gels or sheets, cryotherapy and, in selected cases, surgical removal with additional treatment to reduce recurrence. Treatment depends on the scar’s size, location, symptoms and previous response to treatment. Keloids can return, so ongoing review may be needed.

Frequently Asked Questions About Keloid Scars

What is a keloid scar?

A keloid scar is a raised growth of scar tissue that spreads beyond the boundaries of the original skin injury. It develops when the healing process produces excessive collagen. Keloids can follow acne, ear piercings, surgery, burns or other skin injuries.

What is the difference between a keloid scar and a hypertrophic scar?

A keloid scar grows beyond the original wound, while a hypertrophic scar remains within its boundaries. Hypertrophic scars may gradually flatten over time. Keloids are more likely to persist and may require treatment to reduce their thickness and symptoms.

Why do some people develop keloid scars?

Keloid formation is influenced by an individual’s healing response and genetic susceptibility. People with darker skin tones or a personal or family history of keloids are more likely to develop them. Common sites include the chest, shoulders, upper back, jawline and earlobes.

Do keloid scars go away on their own?

Keloid scars usually persist without treatment. Growth may eventually stop, but the scar can remain raised. Treatment may help flatten the scar and reduce itching, tenderness or discomfort, although complete removal and permanent results cannot be assured.

What is the most effective treatment for keloid scars?

There is no single treatment that works best for every keloid. Corticosteroid injections are commonly used to reduce scar thickness and symptoms. Depending on the scar, a doctor may recommend silicone gels or sheets, cryotherapy, or surgery combined with additional treatment. Some keloids respond better to a combination of treatments.

How do steroid injections treat keloid scars?

Corticosteroid injections are delivered directly into the keloid to reduce inflammation and excessive scar tissue formation. They can help soften and flatten the scar and relieve itching or tenderness. Several sessions may be needed, usually spaced a few weeks apart, depending on the response.

Can a keloid scar return after surgical removal?

Yes. Surgical removal alone carries a high risk of recurrence, and the new keloid may be larger than the original. When surgery is appropriate, doctors usually combine it with additional treatment, such as corticosteroid injections or pressure therapy, to reduce that risk. Recurrence remains possible.

Do silicone gels or sheets help keloid scars?

Silicone gels and sheets may help soften and flatten raised scars and reduce discomfort. They may also form part of care after keloid treatment. They are generally used once the skin has fully healed and require consistent application over several months. Established keloids may need additional treatment.

What are the possible side effects of keloid scar treatment?

Side effects depend on the treatment. Corticosteroid injections can cause discomfort, skin thinning or changes in pigmentation. Cryotherapy can cause blistering and pigment changes, particularly in darker skin. Surgery creates a new wound and carries a risk of further keloid formation. A doctor should explain the relevant risks before treatment.

When should a growing scar be assessed by a doctor?

Arrange an assessment if a scar extends beyond the original wound, continues to enlarge, causes persistent itching or pain, or restricts movement. Early assessment may help guide treatment and limit further growth. A changing skin growth should also be examined if you are unsure whether it is a scar.

Why Won’t My Keloid Scar Stop Growing?
Scroll to top